By: Kayla Peters
No matter where you go in the world, animals are always
being abused. However, nothing seems as horrific as what happens in the fur
farms of China. China provides over 60%
of the world’s fur from animals such as raccoon dogs, black, red and grey
foxes, stray cats and dogs and other typical “fur” species. There is no
labeling system for fur in China so when a coat says “fox fur produced in China,”
it is very seldom true. The coat could be cat, dog, raccoon or fox without any
way to tell for certain. Since there is a huge stray dog problem is Asian
countries, often the solution to reduce the population of stray dogs is to
catch them for either food or fur.
With each farm holding two hundred to three hundred animals,
the animals are subjected to very poor care during their lifetimes and during
their deaths. The average cost to raise an animal for fur is $45CAD yet the
average pelt (fur of the animal) is sold for $89CAD. Chinese claim that since
the cost to raise the animal is so high and the selling prise so low, they
cannot afford humane methods of slaughter for the animals.
In the fur farms there are only a handful of “lucky”
animals. These “lucky” animals slaughtered by a method called anal probing. In
this method, one metal rode is inserted to the animal’s anus while another is
forced down the animal’s throat. The animal is then electrocuted until death. This
method is considered one of the more humane options but is costly so it is
barely used.
The rest of the animals go through a much more painful
event. This method includes beating the animal’s head with a hard object such
as a metal rod, stick, brick, foot or by picking the animal by the hind legs
and slamming him or her to the floor. The object of this is to kill the animal
but the majority of the time, the animal survives this with only a head injury.
The animal is then tied up from their hind legs and they are skinned alive. The
skin is cut around the legs and the person skinning the animal will use their
body weight to pull the skin off from their feet to their head. Once the skin
is removed, the body of the skinless animal is thrown into a pile, like
garbage. What makes this practice so terrifying is not the fact that 90% of the
animals are skinned while still conscious; it is that they will survive for
5-10 minutes after being skinned, eventually dying from heart failure or suffocation
from the other bodies being piled on top of them.
Many wonder how this practice is still allowed, why there
are now laws or regulations surrounding animal welfare. In China, there are
very few laws regarding animal welfare, and when the animal is in a fur farm,
there are none. One of China’s only laws is the Law of the People’s Republic of
China on the Protection of Wildlife, also called the Wildlife Protection Law
(WPL). In this law, it states that any wildlife is considered to be a natural
resource and shall be used as such. Since fur farmer make more money than most Chinese
citizens, they bring in a lot of money for the towns that they are situated in,
therefore fur farming is promoted and fur farmers are considered to be heroes. Fur
farms can also employ up to 50% of an average farming village population either
directly or indirectly.
It seems as though nothing will change the situation in
China regarding the fur industry and that there is very little hope for animal
activists or the animals themselves but it has only been in the past few years
that this issue has been brought to light. With more light being brought to the
issue, less people will find fur products attractive which will decrease the
market for fur and eventually save the lives of thousands of innocent animals.
A shocking
look inside chinese fur farms. (2014, January). Retrieved from Meredith, C.
(2013, March 01). The true face of china's fur farms. Express. Retrieved from http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/381117/Animals-electrocuted-strangled-and-skinned-alive-The-true-face-of-China-s-fur-farms
Tobias, M. (2012, February 01). Animal rights in china.Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltobias/2012/11/02/animal-rights-in-china/http://features.peta.org/ChineseFurFarms/
Tobias, M. (2012, February 01). Animal rights in china.Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltobias/2012/11/02/animal-rights-in-china/http://features.peta.org/ChineseFurFarms/
Blake, M. (2013,
November 25). Chinese "fox farms. Daily mail.
Retrieved from
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2513288/Chinese-Fox-Farms-animals-clubbed-death-skinned-fur-trade.html


You knew a lot about the this topic, a lot of detail and facts to back up what you were saying. I knew that these methods were brutal but I didn't realize to what extremes they went to get the fur. Knowing this information I will defiantly be paying more attention to animal fur. I would like to see more information on if China is working on solutions to help solve this problem.
ReplyDeleteThanks Isabeau, at the moment there is not much that China is doing to try to resolve the issue or employ more humane methods this is because since China is responsible for the majority of the fur trade, they hold a lot of power. However, in late 2011/early 2012, there was a new law that was being written dealing with the protection of animals but this law was not introduced. It does give a bit of hope though because at least there was one attempt at bettering the system, hopefully next time a law will be passed! -Kayla
DeleteWow thank you, that really did help sum up this issue, it was very informative !
DeleteWow I never knew that China controlled so much of the fur trade! Do you think its possible to get legislation to make it illegal to buy and sell animal furs?? I wish I had more information on what specific methods activists are taking to stop it, and do you think its possible to instead of shutting down the industry in china to stop it from being imported to North America?
ReplyDeleteAs I told Isabeau in her comment, there was a bill that was written in order to better the treatment of animals but it was not passed. I do not believe that legislation could make it illegal to buy and sell furs because it is of economical value to China as well as other other countries where fur trade is present.
DeleteThere are two ways that activists target issues: directly and indirectly. The fur trade in China has been targeted by the indirect method. This means that instead of getting the fur farms shut down directly (which would be next to impossible because there are no laws in fur farms therefore no legal wrong doings have occurred), activists have been presenting the information to the public, much as I have in this blog. If the fur consumer realizes what is occurring, fur will become less appealing and the industry will shrink. For example, PETA presented the Angora rabbit fur trade issues to many designers and a few, such as Calvin Klein have officially stated that they will no longer use any Angora rabbit fur!!
As for your last question, there is potential to stop importing in to Canada but it is not likely. Since very little money is spent raising the animals, it is cheaper to import the fur into Canada. In Canada, the anal probing method is used more often and is expensive so importing is much cheaper. Also, if importing were illegal, it would only make the Canadian fur market larger and not solve the issue of fur use in general. Thank you for your questions! -Kayla
Thanks so much for the response. Really informative!!!!
DeleteThis post is really heartbreaking. Coming from someone who used to live in China and plans on moving back there eventually. I never knew that they use the stray dogs for their fur just because they have a lot of them, that's extremly unacceptable. When I first lived in China, we lived not in the best place at the time, and my dad went to throw the garbage out and found a garbage bag that was moving. He opened it and 5 newborn puppies were thrown in the garage on a 30 degree day like trash. It's sad that there is no official law that can stop this. Do you think it's possible that this could be stopped? I wish it had more information that had to do with what people are do to stop it, so we can help.
ReplyDeleteThat is so terrible that that happened to your dad! There is hope for the treatment of stray dogs in China. As I am sure you know, there were millions of people who died in China some time ago so if there was a food source (even dogs or cats) it would be used. Many of the citizens who witnessed this terrible time became accustomed to eating dogs and still do not understand why it is an issue. However today's generation thinks differently. Since the younger citizens didn't experience this, they do not accept eating dogs. Recently, a group of teenagers stood in the middle of the highway to stop 3 trucks filled with 500 000 dogs going to slaughter! However the situation with fur is different because most people in China agree that fur is economically valuable to the country and do not want to stop. Eventually, if there is more light brought to this issue, there is potential that the market will shrink meaning that less animals will be killed for their fur however. Some activists are trying to get China to start properly labeling the fur they produce so people buying the fur will actually know what type of fur they are buying (dog, fox, raccoon dog..). Hopefully their idea will work!
Delete